A South African legend and one of the few African players to win the UEFA Champions League, Benni McCarthy was widely viewed as Kenya’s best hope of leading Harambee Stars to unprecedented heights and potentially challenging for a first-ever AFCON title.
Following his appointment, many Kenyans believed he was the right man to transform the national team, largely because of his impressive playing career and coaching experience, including a stint with Manchester United.
However, that optimism appears to be fading. Recent performances, coupled with McCarthy’s public remarks about the state of Kenyan football, have raised concerns among supporters about the team’s direction ahead of AFCON 2027, which Kenya will co-host.
The concerns are not only about results. Harambee Stars have struggled to show a consistent cutting edge in attack and have failed to register significant victories in competitive matches since their 1-0 World Cup qualifying win over Burundi a year ago.
McCarthy’s Latest Remarks
As the saying goes, a team’s situation is often reflected by its coach, and judging from the former Bafana Bafana striker’s recent comments, confidence within the camp appears to be under strain.
Ahead of an AFCON qualifier against Eritrea, McCarthy described the situation surrounding Harambee Stars, off the pitch, as a “sinking ship.”
He explained that several players of Kenyan heritage had been reluctant to commit to the national team because of previous experiences and the negative stories surrounding the team, the Sports Ministry, and the Football Kenya Federation (FKF).
McCarthy was also asked why he had chosen to remain in charge despite the challenges. He responded that he still believed the situation could improve.
However, following a 1-0 defeat in Guinea during the AFCON qualifiers, the coach doubled down on his assessment of the team’s prospects, arguing that Kenya remains some distance away from competing with Africa’s elite nations, even as the country prepares to host AFCON 2027.
In his own words, the Champions League winner said even if he were to be paid millions and millions of dollars, it would be difficult for Kenya to compete with African powerhouses like Morocco, Egypt, Senegal and Ivory Coast.
“I don’t think Kenya has the resources and a strong enough team to compete with African powerhouses. For us to think that Kenya will win the AFCON is not impossible but it’s highly unlikely,” he said.
For many Kenyan fans, as well as sports journalists sharing their views on social media, the comments have been difficult to accept and have added to growing frustration over the team’s progress since his appointment.
Some supporters believe the remarks suggest a lack of belief in the squad’s potential, while others argue that McCarthy was simply being realistic about the challenges facing Kenyan football.
Regardless of the interpretation, his comments have sparked debate about whether he remains the right person to lead Harambee Stars into one of the most important periods in the country’s football history.
Attention now turns to the FKF leadership and whether they continue to back the South African coach ahead of the crucial fixtures scheduled for November, including a potentially emotional encounter against his home country.
Until then, Kenyan football fans can only hope that Harambee Stars can overcome off-field distractions, focus on their performances, and build momentum ahead of the PAMOJA AFCON 2027 tournament.


